연구논문

하단의 논문은 서울대학교 아시아태평양법연구소 아시아태평양법 국제교류기금의 학술연구비 지원을 받은 학술논문입니다.



김형석, Judging Capacity in Korean Private Law (2019)

아태법
2021-02-09
조회수 219

김형석, "Judging Capacity in Korean Private Law", Journal of Korean Law, Vol. 18, No. 2 (2019), pp. 325-333.

<Abstract>

Most jurisdictions of the civilian tradition assume that a person needs to have a certain degree of mental capacity to take part in legal transactions. The Korean Civil Code also presupposes the capacity to form an intent as a prerequisite of any valid juridical act, although its definition is not expressly given. Doctrine and case law try to understand the concept from a cognitive perspective, concentrating their efforts on scrutinizing the cognitive capabilities of the concerned person. The author disagrees with this approach, whose definition is too vague to handle in practice and has a danger of discrimination. It is instead submitted that volitional elements must be integrated into the concept of capacity. According to this test, the capacity is to be denied only when cognitive disturbances interfere with forming an intent to such a degree that it is impossible to speak of a self-determination. This conclusion is justified by the principle of private autonomy and some convincing examples.

<Keywords>

capacity, capacity to form an intent, private autonomy, contract, will, juridical act



08826 서울특별시 관악구 관악로 1 서울대학교 아시아태평양법연구소 / Tel : 02-880-4119 / E-mail : aplaw@snu.ac.kr

COPYRIGHT 2015 Seoul National University Asia·Pacific Law Institute ALL RIGHT RESERVED. 
개인정보처리방침은 http://aplaw.snu.ac.kr/?mode=privacy를 참조하시기 바랍니다.